Saturday, January 16, 2021
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact
Pension Changes
  • Home
  • Government Policy
  • Pension Changes
  • Pension Information
  • Pension Rights
  • Retirement Pension
No Result
View All Result
Pension Changes
Home Pension Rights

Swatting, stooshies and politicians galore – the politicisation of Mumsnet

October 11, 2020
in Pension Rights
Swatting, stooshies and politicians galore – the politicisation of Mumsnet
0
SHARES
3
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

TEN million people visit Mumsnet every month to talk parenting, pregnancy and politics.

Related posts

Law, Practice and Precedents (8th Edition)

Law, Practice and Precedents (8th Edition)

January 15, 2021
Guest comment: Credit where it’s due

Guest comment: Credit where it’s due

January 15, 2021

From Universal Credit questions to infidelity fears and arguments over Scottish independence and Brexit, the site is so huge that, according to co-founder Justine Roberts, upwards of 45.5 million words are written on its talk boards every month.

The audience commanded by the UK’s biggest parenting site is so broad, dedicated and – crucially – female that politicians clicked onto it years ago, hosting live sessions in a bid to woo users over. More than 100 of these have been held since then-PM David Cameron took part in the first in 2006, with everyone from UKIP to the Women’s Equality Party logging on for their own.

Nicola Sturgeon’s been on, as have Jo Swinson, Mhairi Black and John McDonnell. None are given an easy ride. A session between Alex Salmond and Alistair Darling before the 2014 indyref attracted more than 800 comments, while Gordon Brown was the subject of mockery in 2009 when he failed 12 times to name his favourite biscuit in an incident dubbed “Biscuitgate” by the press.

Such was the impact of that stooshie that every politician who now appears on the site must do so with a quip about shortbread up their sleeve.

But it’s also been the subject of sustained criticism for being too middle class and allowing debate about Gender Recognition Act reform that has been branded transphobic and sparked campaigns aimed at cutting off the advertising the free-to-use site relies on to survive. Margarine maker Flora withdrew last year as the transphobia row continued over debate on the site about the impact of potential law changes on women and children, an action which itself triggered boycott calls by some Mumsnetters and saw Roberts condemn both transphobia and censorship.

Advertisers have also been targeted in other ways by the site’s critics, with Marks & Spencer the subject of a naked protest by Fathers for Justice in 2012 and armed police were sent to arrest Roberts and her husband at their home thanks to a hoax call in a so-called “swatting attack” in the same week that a cyber attack overwhelmed the site.

Now Aberdeen academic Dr Sarah Pedersen examines the support and the stooshies in her new book The Politicisation of Mumsnet.

“It’s had a lot of mud slung at it,” she says. “But I don’t think it’s toxic – it has 10 million users a month and goes from strength to strength, but people who don’t go on it tend to make disparaging comments about it. It has been tarred with a brush that it doesn’t deserve.”

Mumsnet was founded by working mums Roberts and Carrie Longton in 2000 to “make parents’ lives easier by pooling knowledge and experience”. The pair, who met at antenatal classes, have been so successful that the site’s talk boards reached one billion page views last November.

Only 2-5% of users are male, according to estimates, but it’s hard to pin this down because the prevalence of often punny usernames means no-one knows who is typing unless they declare their sex.

Pedersen, a professor of communication and media at Robert Gordon University, compares the forums to the letters pages of Edwardian newspapers – a previous research topic. Women harnessed both, she says, to make political statements about marginalised issues – voting rights, pension rights, the gender pay gap – using pseudonyms to enter “a public sphere dominated by men”.

“I find it fascinating that men on Mumsnet are attempting not to bring attention to their sex,” Pedersen says, “when women often do the same on other parts of the internet.”

“Women often attempt what’s seen as masculine ways of writing in order to participate on other sites but on Mumsnet, men attempt what they see as female ways of writing.

“The irony is that Mumsnetters use these things that are seen as masculine – swearing and an aggressive tone.

“They express anger about the Government, their parents, the children and it’s a safe place for them to do that. They call a spade a spade or even a bloody shovel but they’ll give you advice and it’ll be valuable and useful advice.

“The arguments have to be well articulated and they’ll call out each of them if they’re not.

“There’s a lot of sharing of links and references and the insatiable desire to research has really come to the fore with the threads on Covid, whether that’s the sharing of really obscure medical research articles or items from an Iranian newspaper. There was one where the poster asked ‘does anybody read Farsi?’ Within an hour someone had translated it.”

Mumsnet is, according to the company itself, a “site for grown ups”. Moderation is limited and there’s a commitment to free speech, but there are also strict rules for users to adhere to. Those who don’t will have their content and even their membership removed.

Its active community of users has led to high profile campaigns about rape awareness, miscarriage care and the premature sexualisation of girls.

For all that, you’d think politicians would approach with care, but Pedersen says too many have expected to breeze through webchats on light and “family-friendly” policies without preparing for a forensic grilling.

— to www.thenational.scot

Previous Post

The State Pension age is set to rise again! Here’s how I’d protect myself

Next Post

Impact Assessment (consultation): Climate change risk – governance and disclosure (TCFD)

Next Post
Guaranteed Minimum Pension (GMP) equalisation newsletter – July 2020

Impact Assessment (consultation): Climate change risk – governance and disclosure (TCFD)

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED NEWS

Government formation talks squeezed on several fronts

Government formation talks squeezed on several fronts

8 months ago
How to spend it: ultimate drawdown plan for a £2m pension

How to spend it: ultimate drawdown plan for a £2m pension

4 weeks ago
State pensions and women | Wilts and Gloucestershire Standard

State pensions and women | Wilts and Gloucestershire Standard

6 months ago
Senate approves ‘rainy day’ pension changes

Senate approves ‘rainy day’ pension changes

8 months ago

FOLLOW US

  • 79 Followers
  • 27.6k Followers
  • 40.7k Subscribers

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • Government Pension Policy
  • Pension Changes
  • Pension Information
  • Pension Policy
  • Pension Rights
  • Retirement Pension
  • Uncategorized

BROWSE BY TOPICS

2021 2021 Pensions auto-enrolment age 18 auto enrolment pension contributions 2021/22 auto enrolment rates 2020/21 auto enrolment rates 2021/22 cashing in pension at 55 cashing in pension calculator cashing in small pension pots CCP retirement check my state pension Disabled pensions drawdown employer pension contributions 2021/22 government policy examples uk list of government policies uk minimum pension contributions 2021 minimum pension contributions 2022 new state pension Pension age pension issues pension ombudsman pension plan pension regulator Pensions Advisory Service Pensions Brexit pension scheme uk Pensions outlook retirement 2 million scams scheme funding Single mothers pensions State Pension State Pension age state pension changes state pension forecast State Pensions State triple lock taking pension at 55 the pensions regulator Therese Coffey uk pension age UK State Pension uk state pension age what is government policy uk

POPULAR NEWS

  • Multiemployer pension reform not happening this year

    Multiemployer pension reform not happening this year

    5 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Exit payment cap: Implications for the LGPS

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Public Service Pensions Update | October 2020

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • NEST: More than a pension | Country Report

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Builders were not self-employed, rules employment tribunal

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • Law, Practice and Precedents (8th Edition)
  • State pension payments can be received while working – will more tax need to be paid?
  • What is the average UK retirement income?

Category

  • Government Pension Policy
  • Pension Changes
  • Pension Information
  • Pension Policy
  • Pension Rights
  • Retirement Pension
  • Uncategorized

Recent News

Law, Practice and Precedents (8th Edition)

Law, Practice and Precedents (8th Edition)

January 15, 2021

State pension payments can be received while working – will more tax need to be paid?

January 15, 2021
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2020 Please contact us on partnership@pensionchanges.co.uk if you would like to reach our audience.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home

© 2020 Please contact us on partnership@pensionchanges.co.uk if you would like to reach our audience.