Wednesday, March 3, 2021
  • Contact
Pension Changes
  • Government Policy
  • Pension Changes
  • Pension Information
  • Pension Rights
  • Retirement Pension
No Result
View All Result
Pension Changes
Home Pension Changes

Editorial: California Supreme Court rightly stops one pension abuse

August 6, 2020
in Pension Changes
Editorial: California Supreme Court rightly stops one pension abuse
0
SHARES
0
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

For years, California state workers could sweeten a pension by piling on overtime or unused sick and vacation pay on a final year’s salary and go out the door with a bulked up retirement rate. When a fix was adopted to curb the abuse, public unions sued saying the change tampered with broad pension guarantees.

Now the state Supreme Court is coming down on the side of ending the spendthrift loophole, declaring in a unanimous opinion that the change pushed by then-Gov. Jerry Brown is legal. Known as spiking, the tactic often meant employees could earn more in retirement than they did during working years. Last year, the court also ruled against another practice that let workers buy extra years on the books to fatten pensions. The tactics are among the many reasons that California faces a chasm of debt estimated at nearly $179 billion in future pension obligations.

The court’s ruling was just as important in what it didn’t do. Under scrutiny was the so-called California rule, which largely forbids cutting promised pensions. The spiking issue teed up the larger question about whether lawmakers and employers could trim retirement checks in hard times. With the economy in a virus-caused tailspin, that idea is taking on currency.

But the high court wouldn’t go that far in allowing sweeping pension changes. It sidestepped a direct ruling on the California rule, followed by about a dozen other states, sticking only with the spiking issue. That caution will postpone major changes in meeting future retirement bills.

The upshot is a partial win for both sides. Workers can’t exploit spiking, but they’ll continue to enjoy the general protection against bigger inroads on pension plans. That outcome could have a restraining effect on state and local lawmakers when labor negotiations come up. It’s tempting to kick extra money into retirement pay to win agreement, but it’s hard to undo that future bill when financial trouble looms.

The court may be ending one pension abuse, but it’s circumventing a much larger question on California’s costly pension system.

This commentary is from The Chronicle’s editorial board. We invite you to express your views in a letter to the editor. Please submit your letter via our online form: SFChronicle.com/letters.

— to www.sfchronicle.com

Related posts

Freeports, green recovery and levelling up: What North West business leaders want from Budget 2021

Freeports, green recovery and levelling up: What North West business leaders want from Budget 2021

March 2, 2021
Teachers at Wycliffe College in Stroud to strike over pensions

Teachers at Wycliffe College in Stroud to strike over pensions

March 2, 2021
Previous Post

How State Pension rule changes coming into effect today could delay your retirement

Next Post

Pensions snapshot – August 2020

Next Post
EU Court to Consider if an Irish Pension can be Exempted from a UK Bankruptcy Estate

Pensions snapshot - August 2020

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED NEWS

EDITORIAL: Review pension policy – Business Daily

EDITORIAL: Review pension policy – Business Daily

10 months ago
EU Court to Consider if an Irish Pension can be Exempted from a UK Bankruptcy Estate

The California Supreme Court Addresses the California Rule and Public Retirement System Governance

7 months ago
Labour news: Len McCluskey’s plan to teach trade unionism in school revealed | UK | News

Labour news: Len McCluskey’s plan to teach trade unionism in school revealed | UK | News

10 months ago
Covid-19 and your pension: what you will need to know

Covid-19 and your pension: what you will need to know

9 months ago

FOLLOW US

  • 81 Followers
  • 27.6k Followers

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • Government Pension Policy
  • Pension Changes
  • Pension Information
  • Pension Policy
  • Pension Rights
  • Retirement Pension
  • Uncategorized

BROWSE BY TOPICS

2021 2021 Pensions bbc news CCP retirement check my state pension civil service pension reform Disabled pensions drawdown government policy examples uk how much is state pension lic pension plans Minutes of Meeting new state pension PAB Meeting Minutes PAB Minutes Pension age pension changes announced today pension issues pension meaning pension ombudsman pension plan pension reform definition Pensions Advisory Service Pensions Brexit pension scheme uk Pensions outlook retirement 2 million retirement pension sbi life saral pension plan calculator scams scheme funding Single mothers pensions State Pension State Pension age state pension changes state pension forecast State Pensions State triple lock the pensions regulator Therese Coffey uk pension age uk pension for eu citizens after brexit UK State Pension uk state pension age uk state pension calculator

POPULAR NEWS

  • Multiemployer pension reform not happening this year

    Multiemployer pension reform not happening this year

    5 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Exit payment cap: Implications for the LGPS

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Public Service Pensions Update | October 2020

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • What is the average UK retirement income?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • NEST: More than a pension | Country Report

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • Freeports, green recovery and levelling up: What North West business leaders want from Budget 2021
  • Capital Gains Tax: Rishi Sunak’s Budget may mean ‘stealth’ change to CGT | Personal Finance | Finance
  • Enfield Council slammed over £30m fossil fuel investments

Category

  • Government Pension Policy
  • Pension Changes
  • Pension Information
  • Pension Policy
  • Pension Rights
  • Retirement Pension
  • Uncategorized

Recent News

Freeports, green recovery and levelling up: What North West business leaders want from Budget 2021

Freeports, green recovery and levelling up: What North West business leaders want from Budget 2021

March 2, 2021
Capital Gains Tax: Rishi Sunak’s Budget may mean ‘stealth’ change to CGT | Personal Finance | Finance

Capital Gains Tax: Rishi Sunak’s Budget may mean ‘stealth’ change to CGT | Personal Finance | Finance

March 2, 2021
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2020 Please contact us on partnership@pensionchanges.co.uk if you would like to reach our audience.

No Result
View All Result
  • Contact

© 2020 Please contact us on partnership@pensionchanges.co.uk if you would like to reach our audience.